Talented writer Doranna Durgin has worked very hard to revert the rights to her beautiful novel Dun Lady's Jess from Canadian publisher Fitzhenry & Whiteside. A lot of people have featured this situation, so I am coming a bit late to the situation, thanks to a heads up from Elizabeth Moon.
In today's publishing environment, situations like this are extremely bad. In common language, Doranna agreed with the Canadian publisher to reprint a paperback edition of her book Dun Lady's Jess, which was her first novel, and an award-winning reader favorite with a beautiful story about a horse who is magically transformed into a beautiful young woman, gaining human personality and intelligence, but retaining her inner nature as a horse all along. If you love horses and romantic, exciting fantasy stories, I highly recommend this book, but for the time being, even if you wanted to buy this book from the Canadian publisher Fitzhenry & Whiteside, you would have a challenge.
That is because Fitzhenry & Whiteside has 1,600 copies of the book in a warehouse, but it isn't available outside of direct order from them. They are not putting the book in the wholesale and distributor catalogs that bookstores order from.
Doranna included a specific reversion clause in her contract with this publisher, and they signed it. This type of clause means that if the publisher does not keep the book in print and available in bookstores, the author has the right to ask for her rights back, so she can sell and publish the book elsewhere, and it can be in bookstores.
After many polite and appropriate requests which the publisher denied, Doranna turned to the Science Fiction Writers of America Griefcom. This effective committee is usually able to resolve matters of this type quickly and well. In this case, Fitzhenry & Whiteside were not more cooperative with the Science Fiction Writer committee members. They told Doranna that she could buy all 1,600 books in the warehouse if she wanted the rights to her own work back.
Needless to say, they are not abiding by their contract, and their statement that she should buy these books is not done in the professional publishing industry. When I first read the statement, I was reminded of vanity presses that cheat unsuspecting and inexperienced authors by printing large numbers of books and selling them directly to the author at a high cost.
So . . . don't let this go by. The Fitzhenry & Whiteside representatives even said that the Science Fiction Writers volunteer representatives were "harassing" them by requesting they follow the contract. This is very bad, and Doranna's book should be set free. She should not have to sue this company to enforce her own contract. Even worse, there's no way to understand why the company has done this. It is difficult to see how this would benefit their business, and with the bad publicity now ensuing, it certainly will not.